Home

News
Viewpoints
Letters
Street Beat
Calendar

About us

Feedback

Community Guide
Search


Advanced Search

home : viewpoints : viewpoints September 03, 2010

4/29/2009 10:00:00 PM Email this articlePrint this article 
What's fair when it comes to illegal immigrants?
Arlene Jones

This Friday, May 1, will again bring about marches from people who are in this country illegally and their supporters. Illegal immigration is a very contentious subject. This year it will be even more so as millions of Americans have become unemployed or are facing the "chopping block."

I always have been insulted when individuals who are pro-illegal immigrants try to logic out why one group of people can break one set of laws while the rest of us should be subject to the exact same laws. For example, the City of Chicago has proclaimed itself to be a sanctuary city. We have individuals who get upset if the police do stings and arrest and take the cars of people who are in this country illegally and driving without a license. Yet we recently had an alderman proclaim that the city should take the cars of American citizens who leave traffic court and drive after being told to not do so. Where is the fairness?

I recently spent several months working in a Chicago public school where the student population was half black and half Hispanic. As I walked down the hallways, the classrooms for grades kindergarten through third looked like something out of a movie prior to Brown vs. Board of Education. The classrooms for first graders, for example, had all the black children in one room while all the Hispanic children were in a separate classroom.

Why? Because six years prior, two children were born in the same city and same hospital. The black child went home where he/she learned English even if it was the Ebonics' version. The other child went home with parents who didn't speak English and may be in this country illegally. That child learned Spanish as their first language.

When the time came to go to school, the Hispanic parents were allowed to choose a bilingual education program, even if the child is functional in English.

Wait a second. If the Hispanic children are getting bilingual education, shouldn't the black kids be getting the same opportunity to become bilingual by learning Spanish at the same time the Hispanic children are learning English? Where is the fairness?

Recently, a man testified before congress regarding his daughter who was killed while sitting in her car at a red light. Her car was hit by a drunk driver, who was an illegal immigrant. The father referred to the people listed on the ICE database of illegal immigrants with criminal backgrounds as "banditos." The father was subsequently chastised by Congressman Luis Gutierrez for using the term "banditos." Interestingly enough, it was not because the congressman could point to the term as being derogatory, but because he has chosen to pursue the interest of illegal immigrants over those of U.S. citizens. He was more concerned with how the illegal immigrants were being portrayed than he was about a U.S. citizen being killed by someone who shouldn't have been in the country to begin with. Where is the fairness?

I have watched while a friend of mine lost his restaurant business. Every day he was visited by the city and issued fines for violations that had nothing to do with his food handling. Fines for signage violation. Fines because his video game didn't have a current license even though it was unplugged and facing backwards so that no one could use it. Yet, every day on the streets of Austin, I am seeing unlicensed and unsanitary corn carts sitting on corners vending food. There is no running water to wash hands and, even worse, where do they use the bathroom when they stand on a corner for hours on end?

I saw on North Avenue, by the soon-to-be opened new Menards, a man cooking tacos on the city's sidewalk. I am sure we have tons of Americans who could also put a BBQ pit on a cart and stand on a corner and sell food. Yet it doesn't happen because the city enforces food-handling laws against citizens but not against others. Where is the fairness?

As this year's marches occur, I am anxious to see how illegal immigration will be portrayed. As Americans have lost jobs, houses and their version of the American dream, will we as a country still be gullible enough to believe that there are jobs that we won't do?

CONTACT: www.arlenejones.blogspot.com





Reader Comments


Posted: Friday, May 01, 2009
Article comment by: Chris

Thank you Arlene! Very well said. Although I didn't detect any hatred or racism in your analysis I'm sure some will invent it. Don't let it bother you. It's the only argument they have.

Posted: Friday, May 01, 2009
Article comment by: Rickie P. Brown

Welcome to the to the International Currency Exchange of Chicago.

I thank you Ms. Jones for your observation of con carts in our community, We at the Gateway Project had the thought of creating such carts to allow young people in our community to began some sort of business for themselves. This was met with very stern guidelines by city officials. 1. Licenses, 2. sanitation for food handling certificates 3. Ray, Ray and the stick-up kids.
It seem that everyone but the African American community can began a business with no problem to take the billions of Black earned dollars out of our community. When asking Alderman Emma Mitts to allow Chicago Ave. to be converted into a corridor to the African American community I was told that “Right now is not the time” not the time!
Not the time for black’s to renew the once respected Mon and Pop black business in the community, not the time for our community to showcase it rich heritage and wears? When you yourself suggested that the old Brack factory be transformed into a African American showplace it was met with angar from all political officals and organizations setup to help the community.I agree now with the swine flu being transmitted in this country from Mexico, you would think Mayor Daley, aren’t some of the same people who are selling this product undocumented workers? To lean more about the Gateway Project go to www.rpbconsultinginc.com


Posted: Friday, May 01, 2009
Article comment by: Jillian

I don't think that Ms. Jones is aware that from Middle school onwards students are to complete a two credit language requirement. However many students choose to go beyond that to AP level courses which also fulfills the foreign language requirement in college. There is no reason why African-American students should not be bilingual. It is also up to the parents. My child is eleven and due to travel, private lessons and au pairs, he is fluent in three languages (English, Spanish and French). He plans on taking German in Middle School. If Spanish speaking parents impart their native language on their American-born children more power to them. I myself learned Italian on my nonna's lap.

Posted: Thursday, April 30, 2009
Article comment by: Dave

Arlene, you hit the nail on the head. For too long illegal immigrants have been above the law, NOT being prosecuted for crimes that every American WOULD be prosecuted for. The courts are now trying to say that an illegal immigrant stealing id's isn't a crime, yet if I did it I would go to jail. I am also tired of hearing about illegals doing the jobs that Americans won't do. Really? My grandfather and father USED to be welders, my brother USED to be a contractor, but illegal immigrant STOLE those jobs away from them. Teenagers used to be able to work summer jobs at fast food restaurants, now those jobs are done by illegals and American kids suffer. Illegals also depress our wages. I remember back in 1996 Burger King paid $8.50 an hour, and those jobs were taken by teens, and senior citizens. Now, illegals do it at minimum wage, a DECREASE in pay in a 13 year period. Now, we have the Mexican Flu spreading all over Texas, and these illegals are STILL allowed to go back and forth as they please. It is time for America to wake up and demand to be taken care of FIRST. Send the illegals AND their anchors back to where ever they came from, and seize the assets that they have here in America to pay for their trip back home, and to reimburse the American people for having to subsidize their free health care, free food, free education etc.

Posted: Thursday, April 30, 2009
Article comment by: Deece

This preferential treatment for Hispanic illegal aliens and their offspring is Racism. It is completely unfair to whites, blacks, asians etc...who are in this country legally.


  - Page 1 -  Page 2

Article Comment Submission Form
Please feel free to submit your comments.

Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor, who may edit content for appropriateness. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the web site editor reviews and approves it.

Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number and e-mail address are for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
Name:
Telephone:
E-mail:
Passcode: This form will not send your comment unless you copy exactly the passcode seen below into the text field. This is an anti-spam device to help reduce the automated email spam coming through this form.

Please copy the passcode exactly
- it is case sensitive.
Message:
   





Copyright 2010, Austin Weekly News,
141 S. Oak Park Ave., Oak Park, IL 60302, 773/626-6332

To view any of the other publications owned and operated by
Wednesday Journal, Inc., click on the appropriate title.

Wednesday Journal Riverside Brookfield Landmark
Chicago Journal Forest Park ReviewChicago Parent magazine


Software © 1998-2010 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved